Angela Merkel, Mariano Rajoy and Mario Monti (Efe).
Reuters 07/24/2012 (10:09 AM CET)
While only a fool could look on recent history and say that markets must always remain untrammeled, the instinctual urge to suppress reality by stopping investors from acting in their own perceived best interests is usually counterproductive. It is also always a screaming sell signal, one that investors will put into action regardless of regulation.
Italy re-introduced a ban on short selling - bets that securities will fall in price - of financial stocks, this time for one week. Spain went further: banning for three months short selling for all Spanish shares, as well as index short bets, or any similar trade in derivatives on or off of established exchanges.
While the ban helped Spanish and Italian shares to reverse earlier sharp losses, selling of government bonds continued as investors demanded a record rate of interest of 7.4 percent to hold Spanish 10-year debt. Italian 10-year bonds also fell, taking their yield to 6.38 percent.
Little wonder: both countries are in difficult straits, short-selling bans do nothing to change that, and, plainly, have a terrible track record for success. Both countries are facing growing financing needs, made more complicated by a disturbingly incomplete picture of the borrowing needs of their regional governments and the stresses this will place on the European Financial Stability Facility.
"It's called contagion," economist David Rosenberg, of Gluskin, Sheff in Toronto wrote in a note to clients. "The problem is that there isn't enough in the EFSF kitty to bail out the Spanish sovereign, its banks and its regions, and then have to deal with Italy. The breakup of the euro zone is no longer a taboo topic, even at the highest level at the EU and IMF."
A little history
Anyone with a memory or access to Google can easily find out exactly how successful these bans will be. A year ago in August, Italy, Spain as well as France and Belgium enacted short-selling restrictions as shares in their banking industries plunged. Patently Europe's economy is now worse and its banking system remains intact only due to the grace and favor of liquidity from the ECB and pledges of official support and capital. Those shorting European shares a year ago were correct, both in analysis and in outcome.
Matters descended into farce in November when Carlo Giovanardi, at the time undersecretary in Silvio Berlusconi's government in charge of family policy and drug prevention, laid the blame for volatility in Milan's bourse on stimulant abuse by traders, a matter he thought might merit mandatory drug testing. The question of what drugs the traders were taking when bidding Italian banks up during the boom was not asked.
Or recall the $1 trillion bailout the EU launched in May of 2011 claiming it would effectively curb "wolfpack behavior" in financial markets. ... The problem isn't with the wolves, it is with the caribou. And remember too that much of Europe, along with most of the rest of the developed world, slapped short-selling bans on their exchanges during the darkest days of the financial crisis in the last three months of 2008. Patently this did nothing to address the euro zone's structural flaws, which weren't even the focus of concern at that point.
A study by economists Alessandro Beber and Marco Pagano of short selling bans around the world during the 07-09 period was damning. They found that the bans hurt market liquidity, retarded price discovery and, with the possible exception of U.S. financial shares, failed to support prices.
Short-selling bans are, and are perhaps intended to be, a side-show, an effort by officials with little else to offer to seem as if they are taking matters in hand. If Italy and Spain had genuine solutions to their banking and debt woes they clearly would not need to suppress price discovery.
This article was published by Reuters.
MORE IN ECONOMY & BUSINESS
ACCORDING TO THE EUROPEAN CENTRAL BANK'S NEW PLAN
Eduardo Segovia (06:00).- The Spanish government will not only benefit from the new bond purchase program, announced by the European Central Bank on Thursday – known as the outright monetary transactions, OMT. It will also benefit from the decision...
PRIVATE CAPITAL MUST REACH 50 PERCENT TO AVOID PUBLIC DEBT
Eduardo Segovia (06:00).- The Spanish government’s plan for the so called ‘bad bank’ to attract a majority of its capital from private investors seems to be running into trouble already. The creation of a ‘bad bank,’...
HUGE CASINO AND HOTEL COMPLEX OUTSIDE SPANISH CAPITAL
Marcos Lamelas (06:00).- The US casino mogul Sheldon Adelson, chairman of Las Vegas Sands, holds an extra board meeting for two day on Thursday and Friday in Nevada to decide whether Eurovegas, a huge hotel and casino complex, will be placed in Madrid or Barcelona. ...